Dialogue on the Threshold

Schwellendialog

28 June 2024

Cœnæsthesis (1)

First of all, it is noteworthy that a state of consciousness at any one moment is an exceedingly complex thing. It is made up of a mass of feelings and active impulses which often combine and blend in a most inextricable way. External sensations come in groups, too, but as a rule they do not fuse in apparently simple wholes as our internal feelings often do. The very possibility of perception depends on a clear discrimination of sense-elements, for example, the several sensations of colour obtained by the stimulation of different parts of the retina. But no such clearly defined mosaic of feelings presents itself in the internal region: one element overlaps and partly loses itself in another, and subjective analysis is often an exceedingly difficult matter. Our consciousness is thus a closely woven texture in which the mental eye often fails to trace the several threads or strands. Moreover, there is the fact that many of these ingredients are exceedingly shadowy, belonging to that obscure region of sub-consciousness which it is so hard to penetrate with the light of discriminative attention. This remark applies with particular force to that mass of organic feelings which constitutes what is known as cœnæsthesis, or vital sense.
 
James Sully, Illusions: A Psychological Study, New York, 1891 


03 June 2024

Possible worlds


Warum wandern die Tschuktschen aus ihrem schrecklichen Lande nicht aus, überall würden sie besser leben, im Vergleich zu ihrem gegenwärtigen Leben und zu ihren gegenwärtigen Wünschen. Aber sie können nicht; alles, was möglich ist, geschieht ja; möglich ist nur das, was geschieht.
 
Franz Kafka, Tagebücher, 5. Januar 1914
 
Why do the Chukchi not leave their dreadful land, anywhere else they would live a better life, in comparison with their present life and their present wants. But they cannot; all that is possible does happen, only that which happens is possible.